Github Issues

You create, update, query, and comment on GitHub (or GitLab) issues.

Rules Overview

CLI vs MCP Precedence

Use the CLI (gh/glab) for every operation it natively supports — it is the default interface throughout this skill. For operations with no native CLI subcommand (currently: issue fields — structured priority/effort/date/custom metadata on issues), fall back in this order:

1. GitHub MCP server tools, if such a server is connected. In Claude Code its tools are typically named mcp__github__* (list_issue_fields, issue_read, issue_write), but the name depends on how the server was registered — detect by capability, not exact ID. Never assume the server is available. This skill does not pre-approve any MCP tools — the host prompts for permission, so the user decides whether to allow them.
2. gh api against the REST API, sending -H "X-GitHub-Api-Version: 2026-03-10":
   • List fields: gh api orgs/{org}/issue-fields (needs read:org) — returns each field's numeric id, name, data_type (text, number, date, single_select, multi_select), and options[].name
   • Read an issue's values: gh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/issues/{number}/issue-field-values
   • Add or update values without touching others: POST to the same path with --input - and a body of {"issue_field_values":[{"field_id":1,"value":"High"}]}. Single-select takes the option name, multi-select an array of names, number a number, date YYYY-MM-DD
   • PUT to the same path replaces all field values on the issue — avoid it unless that is the intent
   • Clear one field: DELETE repos/{owner}/{repo}/issues/{number}/issue-field-values/{field_id} (404 if the field has no value)
3. Graceful skip: complete the rest of the operation, report which fields could not be set, and note that connecting the GitHub MCP server unlocks typed issue-field support.

Workflow

1. Determine action: create, update, query, or comment
2. Detect the remote host from git remote get-url origin (github.com → gh, gitlab.com → glab; default GitHub) and use that CLI throughout. Get owner/repo (or group/project) info. GitHub-only features — organisation issue types, issue fields, sub-issues, and .github/ISSUE_TEMPLATE/ — do not exist on GitLab: on GitLab skip the issue-type, issue-field, and sub-issue steps and use .gitlab/issue_templates/ plus description checklists instead
3. Check for issue templates in the host's conventional location: on GitHub .github/ISSUE_TEMPLATE/ or .github/; on GitLab .gitlab/issue_templates/
4. List available organisation issue types (fails for user-owned repos — expected, proceed without)
5. List available issue fields (organisation-level, inherited by repositories) via the CLI vs MCP precedence above — no native CLI subcommand exists, so use the MCP server or gh api (fails for user-owned repos — expected, proceed without). Organisations get four defaults: Priority (single-select: Urgent, High, Medium, Low), Effort (single-select: High, Medium, Low), Start date, and Target date. Treat them as likely-present but still discover them at runtime — an organisation may have renamed, removed, or added options
6. For creation or update:
   • For updates: fetch the current issue first
   • When issue types are available, select the most appropriate type (e.g. Bug for defects, Feature for new functionality, Task for general work)
   • When the user specifies field values (priority, effort, dates, custom), set them via the CLI vs MCP precedence above — values must match the field's declared type (single-select option name, text, number, YYYY-MM-DD date)
   • When Priority and Effort exist but the user did not specify them, propose a value for each from the issue's content — severity and blast radius for Priority, expected scope of the change for Effort — and say what you picked. Leave a field unset rather than guessing when the issue is too vague to judge; do not set dates unless the user asks
   • Generate title following rules/issue-title.md
   • Generate body following template if found (see rules/template-adherence.md), otherwise use clear structured format
   • For creation: get the current authenticated user and include in assignees
   • If the user specifies a parent issue, link the created/updated issue as a sub-issue (use the issue's node ID, not its number)
7. For parent/sub-issue management:
   • To list sub-issues: get the parent issue's sub-issues
   • To add a sub-issue: pass the parent issue number and the child's node ID
   • To remove a sub-issue: unlink the child from the parent
   • To reorder sub-issues: reprioritise with after_id or before_id
   • When creating multiple related issues, prefer structuring them as a parent with sub-issues rather than flat independent issues
8. For queries:
   • Fetch a specific issue by number
   • Inspect sub-issue hierarchy on a parent issue
   • Search issues for filters, keywords, and cross-repo lookups
   • Filter by issue-field values (MCP field_filters or the API; no native CLI equivalent — degrade gracefully per the precedence above)
   • List repository issues
9. For comments:
   • Fetch issue context first when needed
   • Add the comment to the issue
10. Display a summary with issue links and what changed

Validation

• For titles: follow rules/issue-title.md
• For body with template: follow rules/template-adherence.md
• For labels: only use labels that already exist in the repository
• For fields: only set fields that already exist in the organisation or repository; never invent field names or single-select options
• For assignees: only assign valid repository collaborators